The Offences Against the Person Act 1861 is one hundred and fifty years old today, 6th of August 2011. The Act is very much alive and well, although much of the Act has been repealed it is still one of the cornerstones of our criminal laws that protect us from assault, wounding and harm.
The basis of all medical treatment is that there should be a disease or injury that needs treatment and that the patient should personally consent to such treatment.
There are of course exceptions (see the post Consent and circumcision) but informed personal consent becomes crucial when the treatment being sought is non-therapeutic. If a doctor treats a patient who has no disease or injury and cannot personally consent to such treatment then the doctor has no defence of reasonable surgery and is probably committing a crime under the Offences Against the Person Act 1861.
It would appear to folow that the non-therapeutic circumcision of boys who are healthy and, being minors, cannot personally consent to a non-therapeutic procedure, is a crime. It is quite surprising that no prosecutions have been brought to date.
New to MDC?
Sign up for free newsletter
- RT @TakeThatForeski: The end of #FGM will occur at the same time as the end of #RIC: all cultures that cut girls also cut boys: they are in… 09:35:16 PM July 03, 2015 ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @briandavidearp: Deep dog thoughts. http://t.co/5o8CT77v72 08:07:47 AM July 03, 2015 ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @TheKingsFund: We issue a stark warning about NHS finances ahead of #budget2015 http://t.co/grk3KhjCih http://t.co/IEzXl4qhaB 07:31:14 AM July 03, 2015 ReplyRetweetFavorite